The Art of Persuasion – Assignment 1

Joshua Houston (s3663263)

Can something be both political and poetic?

Any subject, regardless of how mundane or audacious, can be written and presented as poetry. Politics refers process of making decisions to apply to members of a group, and though politics is often referenced in regards to elected leaders of the country, politics can also refer to the policies and rules that apply to people every day. The subject of politics is not exempt from being presented in an unorthodox way, and people who feel they are discriminated against with the rules and policies that are presented to them may feel the need to express their disdain with a poetic style. A classic example of this are the speeches delivered by rights activists.

“I have a dream that my poor little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the colour of their skin but by the content of their character”

Martin Luther King

However, Terry Eagleton, a critic and Professor of English Literature at Lancaster University, argues that poetry is emotive, original, and sensuously particular, with the texture of personal experience, whereas politics is a question of abstract notions, impersonal institutions, and collective entities. (1) Politics involves well defined determinant ideas, whereas poetry thrives on ambiguity and ambivalence.

 

What is the role of formal experimentation in political documentary?

Because documentary as its own genre is so difficult to summarise, it’s important to push the limits of what can be considered a documentary in order to create an agreeable definition and recognise the constraints of the category. Formal Experimentation as shown in the Week 1 lecture, include implementing unorthodox themes and media, such as singing your situation in a documentary rather than speaking it, or showing still images with sound rather than a video.

“Increased experimentation by film-makers such as Michael Moore and Morgan Spurlock means that the walls between art and documentary are collapsing, generating innovative ideas and attracting an entirely new audience. ” (2)

Sam King

I searched Google for popular documentaries and found many documenting about what everybody would agree is considered political, like war, terrorism, conspiracy theories, and presidential affairs. A documentary that stood out to me was one directed and hosted by Michael Moore in 1989, before he was renown as a filmmaker. The documentary was titled “Roger and Me”. Despite following the somewhat depressing story about General Motors closing all of its plants and leaving 30,000 people unemployed, Moore approaches the topic in a humorous and light-hearted way. In the documentary, he tries to interview the CEO of General Motors Roger Smith, and the cameraperson documents his failed attempts with receptionists sending him away and compilates them for comedic effect. Moore also interviews ex workers and general motors associates with a more sombre tone.

Moore’s experimentation of how he structured the political documentary, made it more personable, and reached a larger audience because of that.

 

 

 

  1. Battersby Eileen, Aug 1996, The politics of poetry, Irish Times; Dublin

  2. Truth or Dare: Art and Documentary Editors: Gail Pearce and Cahal McLaughlin M2 PRESSWIRE-December 3, 2007

Clip Analyse Exercise

 Clip #1 Increased Senses

                ASMR, Intimate, Freedom, Warm,

-change in pace with death-  eerie, loud,

 

Clip #2 The Duke of Burgundy

Calm, Peaceful, colourful, intricate, beautiful (specific focal points)

-change after intro- quiet, lonely

 

Clip #3 Aliens

 

                Cold, Dangerous, Emergency, Confusion,  

scene with mother warm, safe,

bomb approaching explosion stayed calm instead of getting more intense.

PB1: Statement of Intent

 Joshua Houston 

 

 

The reason I’m particularly interested in the Mechanics of Immersion is that I’d like to know what changes a boring student film into an interesting and immersive short film. I would like to learn what it is that editors, actors, and directors think and practice to make their films successful compared to amateurs. I would like to learn how to convey emotion with the use of cinematography, and audio effectively and without using the cliché techniques.

Personally, I’ve listened to music that has really had me drawn in to experience the piece rather than listen to it, predominantly by artists like Pink Floyd and Simon and Garfunkel, but also subgenres like Lofi and Binaural Beats. I understand that the artists create the experience often with ambience, contrasting volumes, speed, and frequencies, but I would like to be able to practice this myself, learning the order that these techniques should go in. I would like to learn to be more critical of movies and music that attempts to create this experience, and decide whether the experience is created following a formula, or a more original approach. Aside from audio, I’ve enjoyed movies such as Mad Max, and the Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless mind, which uses cinematography, music and sound to create very immersive experiences. I’d like to become familiar and more observant with the techniques they use and the planning that goes into them. I understand that video is a more complicated medium, but I would like to leave the class knowing that I could create a piece of video that would keep the viewer entertained rather than thinking it was just another generic student film.

Lastly, aside from the observable techniques, I’d like to learn about why the brain perceives certain subject matter as immersive, what makes those things so enveloping, and how that influences what people create in order to stimulate it.

 

In short, I would like to leave The Mechanics of Immersion Studio with

  • A reasonable understanding of an audio making application
  • Having produced work that I can consider to be immersive and captivating, both audio and visual
  • Have a more critical awareness of how directors, musicians, editors and actors create a captivating experience
  • Understand why and how the brain responds to an immersive experience.

 

I declare that in submitting all work for this assessment I have read, understood and agree to the content and expectations of the assessment declaration.

Josh and Sam Immersive Experience Practice Reflection

Sam and I set out to record footage that was immersive through the use of symmetry, the rule of thirds, and camera techniques such as panning and zoom. We wanted to contrast but also show the similarities between man made structures and nature scenery, we also wanted to portray this in a flowing and easy to digest manner, similar to that of a nature documentary.

Following the recordings, we edited the footage to make to make the brightness, saturation and exposure matched the subject matter. For example, we had the shots of nature that were bright and colourful, contrasting the footage of man made structures were more greyscale. We wanted to edit the footage very lightly so that it wasn’t obvious that there was much post production. We also had the transitions between each footage soft and easy to follow.

Originally, we wanted our footage to follow a narrative or motif, and we had decided on a paper plane or a marble that the camera could follow. But as we tried to put our ideas into practice, the variables like the objects direction made the process very difficult, so we resorted to focusing on camera shots and angles rather than focusing on a story.

Our first shot transitioned from greyscale to colour as it panned up from busy streets to a skyline with birds flying in, which linked to the second shot coming down from the trees and the skyline. From this, we were able to pull back away from nature through the brick wall, loosely representing the confinement of people. The piece finished by showing the contrast of the city roads against bright dying flowers to a bright view of the sun from a garden.

I declare that in submitting all work for this assessment I have read, understood and agree to the content and expectations of the assessment declaration.

Week 10 Workshop: Howard Dully’s Lobotomy (as an audio piece)

In this workshop, as well as talking about sound’s perspective and social distance (Mentioned in previous post) we examined the audio documentary regarding Howard Dully’s trans-orbital Lobotomy. The audio piece followed Howard through trying to look into the reasons that his parents decided to have him receive a frontal lobe lobotomy. I found it very difficult to examine the audio essay conventions being used, as the story itself was very interesting.

Howard mostly speaks during the audio documentary, but often when the story progresses, music will be played in the background. Throughout the documentary there are snippets of quotes from people like Walter Jackson Freeman, the doctor who performed the lobotomy, and a few snippets of other guests often regarding new information.

Overall the audio is very straight to the point, and up until the point where Howard talks to his father, there isn’t much of a pause to take in the emotion.

Workshop 4-5-17 Learning the zoom, and research skills

In this workshop, we discussed posts on the internet that aren’t considered authentic, and to basically not trust everything that we read. We were also put into groups for the PB4 assignment. I was set in a group with Qiming Zhang and Matthew James.

We discussed what we’d learnt in the lecture regarding research in contrast to academic research. Research is a core Media Making Skill, not just an academic skill. Talking to people is good, but needs to complimented by reading/researching.

Academic Research: Souring information from multiple sources to make a well-educated and logical decision and conclusion

Research: Having biased research and information based on other people opinions and often marketing schemes.

Our focus on knowledge produced within Media Studies as an academic discipline, we should be looking at a topics core principles, references, abstracts, conclusions and Works that are cited and peer reviewed. Journals are created by multiple academics, and reviewed by multiple (and often anonymous) sources, which is why they’re a very trusted form of information.

Lastly we figured out how to effectively use the Zoom H2N. Parts that I noted were the fact we could change the direction in which the microphone would record, either surrounding the microphone, or pointing in a particular direction (uni-directional,bi-directional or omni-directional). and other parts like connecting to a computer, and formatting the card.

PB4 draft feedback.

We presented our audio draft to one of the media practitioners named Catherine. After listening to the first few minutes, she old us that we delivered our lines with hesitance, and that we should have our lines more rehearsed and to make the points we make more precise, which I somewhat agreed with. However, we had decided to go for more of a radio talk show kind of feel. With that in mind, Catherine said that we could create an interesting dynamic of discussing our ideas and talking our essay whilst driving in the car, to give it a more talk show feel, and also create an interesting soundscape. Lastly, Catherine said that we should make the dymanic between the 3 of us known, with Qiming’s shy silence, and the age difference between Matt and I.

With this in mind, Matt, Qiming and I set out to create

  • More precise ideas within individual audio recordings
  • A audio recording done in the car, on the way to the vox pop
  • An interesting dynamic between the 3 of us.