This week in documentary as action was the first week of the ‘week in progress’ presentations. Matt and myself chose this week to present as we knew previously one session of our shooting would be done, however the other would not of, making this the perfect opportunity for us to find out exactly what people thought of our work so far, and what other things we could aim to film in our next session at Good Shepherd.
We very quickly put together our best interview footage, this being of the sewing tutor Wendy, and added some b-roll to give the class an idea of what we were planning to create from our shooting. We both already knew that the footage needed some work. There was a lot of sewing talk that needed to be cut out, and some music and smoother editing could have been used.
I was happy overall with the reception we received from the class about what we had put together so far. Some people said they really enjoyed what we had been able to produce which was fantastic to hear, as it showed there was genuine interest in our topic and the story itself. I was a little concerned the piece could be boring so to get this feedback was very important.
A lot of the improvement feedback we received was expected from our own viewings of the piece so far, although some of the things we did not pick up in our first viewing.
First of all, Wendy very early on mentions a woman named ‘Hilary’ which she then ends up doing a number of times throughout the interview without ever really clarifying who she is. For Matt and myself, and Wendy and the other Good Shepherd members, it is very obvious who she is referring to, however, for those who have never met her before or for those who not know anything about Good Shepherd, the mention of her name might be confusing, and may cause the audience to wonder who she is and if she is important to the story they are watching. We will need to find a way in the editing process to clear this up, whether we remove sections where she is mentioned, or potentially use some footage of her that shows off her position or the way she interacts with the group to introduce her properly to the audience.
Some other comments we received was that we should try and use some archival or past photos to try and highlight the group and the overall time of the class, which is something Matt and myself will definitely take into account. I personally enjoy documentaries that show past photos and how things have changed, so I would be very interested in at least showing some images of the women when the class started and Wendy during the three years she has been part of the class. I would also be interested in potentially showing some images of Wendy completing her own sewing, as she highlights throughout her interview that sewing is her passion.
It was also suggested that we use some music within the piece, which was definitely our plan, particularly in the end to heighten that raw emotion that the audience will see throughout Wendy herself. We will look through the creative commons music online and play around with some tracks to find the one that suits the mood of the documentary. We may even decide further down the track that a number of songs are needed throughout, however we won’t know this until we start editing.
B-roll is something else that came up that we would definitely like to extend. At this point the piece is made up of many minutes of simple talking from Wendy. We did not have much time to edit, and seeing as we do want to go back and get more b-roll, we only wanted to put small slices in so we could show what our basic plan was. In our initial shoot we did capture a lot of b-roll we are happy with, however, now we have the interview and our feedback, we will film some more to fill in what we see as the gaps and build ourselves a cohesive piece.
We finally discussed the length on the piece. The current piece sits at around four and a half minutes in length, however when watching it I did notice there were certain bits that were far too dragged out or unnecessary to the piece. A lot of the sewing talk and the actual structure of the class needs to be removed. Certain parts of the interview could also be moved around, and the beginning needs to be worked on to drag the audience in from the beginning.
In terms of our own progress, we will be heading into Good Shepherd this coming Thursday to continue to complete some filming. This is the final week that the class will run, so we need to try and capture as much footage of the women as we can on this day, that way, if we do need to go back, its more so to speak with the Good Shepherd volunteers and workers as they will be more accessible. The women will be receiving a certificate for completing the class, so incorporating this as b-roll into our piece about the women could be interesting. From our last shooting day, we found that the interview with all four women did not work as well as we hoped. With many of the questions, one of the women would answer and the others would not elaborate on what the other said. Because of this, we will try to do some more one on one interviews in this session to gain some more interview footage and voice over pieces to use. We hope to get some more ‘gold’ footage from the women, as well as structure some more open conversations between the women to use as b-roll footage. In our next session, or possibly at a later date, we may also interview Hilary from the community house and possibly some volunteers who know the women to add an extra layer. We hope to fill most of the gaps our film has, and begin editing to see how we can put all the feedback we received into practice.
As a whole, I am very happy with the feedback we received, and think that it mostly matches the path we plan to take with our documentary. We will keep this feedback in mind during our shooting this coming week, and also as we edit and make the other sections of our documentary series!